Tales of upheavals

These two recent readings of mine give me insights to understanding today’s chaotic world.

In his latest work, “Upheaval: Turning Points for Nations in Crisis,” acclaimed author Jared Diamond explores the intriguing and complex nature of national crises and the factors that determine a nation’s ability to overcome them. Drawing on his expertise in history, geography and anthropology, Diamond presents a compelling analysis of pivotal moments in the histories of several nations, providing valuable insights into the challenges they faced and the strategies they employed to navigate through tumultuous times.

Diamond’s writing style is engaging and accessible, allowing both scholars and general readers to delve into the subject matter with ease. Through a combination of historical accounts, personal anecdotes and rigorous analysis, he paints a comprehensive picture of the intricate dynamics involved in nation-building during times of crisis. His approach combines a deep understanding of human psychology with a broad perspective on historical events, resulting in a thought-provoking examination of how nations can overcome adversity.

The book is structured around 12 key factors that Diamond identifies as crucial for a nation’s successful response to a crisis. These factors include national identity, national consensus, honest self-appraisal, the ability to learn from others and the willingness to change core values. Each factor is meticulously explored through multiple case studies, ranging from Finland’s experience during the Second World War to Japan’s response to the Meiji Restoration.

One of the book’s strengths is Diamond’s ability to provide a global perspective. While many studies of nation-building and crises tend to focus on Western nations, Diamond includes examples from various parts of the world. By examining countries as diverse as Chile, Indonesia and Australia, he demonstrates that the challenges faced by nations in crisis are not limited to any particular region or culture.

Diamond’s use of personal anecdotes adds a compelling human element to the book. Sharing his experiences and interactions with individuals from different nations, he illustrates the impact of crisis on ordinary people and the significance of their actions in shaping the course of history. These personal stories, combined with in-depth research and analysis, bring a richness and depth to the narrative that keep readers engaged throughout.

While Upheaval provides valuable insights into the dynamics of nation-building during times of crisis, some readers may find the book slightly repetitive. Diamond often reiterates his 12 key factors and frequently references previous examples. While this repetition reinforces the book’s core concepts, it may be slightly tedious for readers seeking new insights with each case study. However, this does not detract significantly from the overall quality of the work.

Another potential limitation is the absence of more recent case studies. Given the book’s publication in 2019, it would have been interesting to see Diamond explore more recent crises and turning points, such as the Arab Spring or the Brexit referendum. However, this does not diminish the book’s value as a comprehensive examination of historical turning points.

In conclusion, Upheaval: Turning Points for Nations in Crisis is a captivating and enlightening book that offers valuable perspectives on the challenges nations face during times of upheaval. Jared Diamond’s interdisciplinary approach, blending history, psychology and personal narratives, provides readers with a deeper understanding of the complexities of nation-building and crisis management. Despite minor repetitive elements, the book is accessible, well-researched and thought-provoking. It is recommended for anyone interested in history, political science or the intricacies of navigating crises on a national scale.

*   *   *

“The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society” by Nicholas A. Christakis embarks on a captivating exploration of the biological and cultural forces that have shaped human behavior and society throughout history. Through a multidisciplinary approach, Christakis synthesizes insights from evolutionary biology, sociology, anthropology and psychology to shed light on the fundamental underpinnings of our social nature.

The book challenges the dichotomy between nature and nurture, arguing that our behavior is not solely determined by genetics or culture but emerges from a complex interplay between the two. Christakis posits that our social instincts, which include cooperation, friendship and social influence, have deep evolutionary roots. He presents evidence and compelling arguments to support the notion that these instincts have played a pivotal role in the success and survival of human societies across time.

Christakis deftly guides readers through intricate studies and research findings, making the book approachable for both academics and general readers interested in the origins of human society.

The author emphasizes the importance of understanding our evolutionary past as a means to navigate present challenges and create a more equitable and cooperative future.

Throughout the book, Christakis skillfully weaves together a tapestry of examples and anecdotes, illustrating how our social nature shapes various aspects of human life. Whether exploring the formation of social networks, the spread of social norms or the evolution of morality, the author presents a compelling case for the profound influence of our evolutionary origins on society’s fabric.

It does not shy away from acknowledging the complexities and challenges inherent in human behavior and societal dynamics. Christakis acknowledges the potential for both positive and negative manifestations of our social instincts, highlighting the need for conscious and intentional efforts to cultivate a better society.

It offers a rich synthesis of scientific research, illuminating how biology and culture intertwine to shape human society, with a wealth of evidence from diverse fields.

*      *      *

Email: [email protected]